Back

Case Analysis: Lois and James Sumpter

Case Analysis: Lois and James Sumpter

3:00

Case Study: The Sumpters

Meeting Lois

  • 35 years old, office manager
  • Married to James for 8 years
  • Two children, ages 6 and 4

The Beginning

Isolation Begins

  • Criticized Lois's friends and family
  • Insisted on knowing her whereabouts
  • Became jealous of time with others

Financial Control

Emotional Abuse Escalates

  • Called her stupid and worthless
  • Criticized her parenting constantly
  • Made her feel she couldn't survive alone

Using Children as Control

The First Physical Incident

The Pattern Continues

  • Tension builds over days or weeks
  • Explosive incident occurs
  • Apologies and promises follow
  • Calm period, then cycle repeats

Why Lois Stayed

Identifying the Tactics

  • Isolation from support system
  • Economic abuse and dependence
  • Emotional abuse destroying self-worth
  • Using children as tools
  • Physical violence and intimidation

What Type of IPV?

Recognizing Real Cases

Slide 1 of 13

Preparing to Review a Real Case

Case Analysis: Lois and James Sumpter

It can be difficult to imagine all of the elements you've learned happening in a real-life scenario. In this section, you review the case of Lois and James Sumpter.

Content Warning:

This case includes detailed written descriptions of abuse and may be difficult to read. If you find engaging with this content too difficult or jarring, you can take breaks as needed while reviewing the written case details.

What You'll Learn:

As you review the case, you will be guided through the audio and timeline of the events that occurred. This case will help you:

  • See how the Power and Control Wheel manifests in real situations
  • Understand how different types of abuse work together over time
  • Recognize patterns that may not be obvious from isolated incidents
  • Apply the concepts you've learned to actual experiences

📅 Interactive Case Timeline

Click on each event to explore the details and identify Power & Control tactics

💡 Reflection: As you reviewed this timeline, notice how the abuse escalated gradually. Early tactics like isolation and economic control laid the groundwork for later violence. This systematic pattern is what distinguishes intimate terrorism from other forms of relationship conflict.

Analyzing the Case Through the Power and Control Wheel

Identifying Patterns and Tactics

As you engage with the Sumpter Case, think about the types of abuse you encounter. Consider these questions:

Types of Abuse:

  • What types of abuse can you identify in this case?
  • How do different forms of abuse overlap and reinforce each other?
  • Which behaviors fit into physical, emotional, economic, or sexual abuse categories?

Power and Control:

  • How does James Sumpter create and use a power imbalance?
  • Which sections of the Power and Control Wheel do you see represented?
  • How do the tactics on the inside of the wheel relate to the violence on the outside?

The Pattern:

  • Is this intimate terrorism, situational couple violence, or violent resistance?
  • What evidence helps you make this determination?
  • How does the timeline reveal escalation or patterns of control?

What the Case Illustrates

This case exemplifies how the Power and Control Wheel can be used to illustrate to survivors how what they experience contributes to an environment in which a person who causes harm creates and uses a power imbalance to gain control in the relationship.

For professionals like James providing IPV advocacy or Maria conducting intake assessments, being able to recognize these patterns is essential for trauma-informed support.

Applying Your Knowledge

Using the Tools You've Learned

The Sumpter case demonstrates how the tools you've learned in this module come together:

The Power and Control Wheel helps you:

  • Identify specific tactics being used
  • See how behaviors on the inside of the wheel create a foundation for violence on the outside
  • Understand the systematic nature of abuse

Types of Abuse understanding helps you:

  • Recognize that abuse takes many forms beyond physical violence
  • See how different types compound and reinforce each other
  • Identify early warning signs before escalation occurs

Johnson's Typology helps you:

  • Categorize the pattern of violence
  • Understand the context and dynamics of the relationship
  • Provide appropriate resources and support

Interactive Power and Control Wheel

Click or use keyboard (Tab/Arrow keys/Enter) to explore the tactics used in the Sumpter case

PHYSICAL VIOLENCE SEXUAL VIOLENCE POWER & CONTROL Coercion & Threats Using Intimidation Emotional Abuse Using Isolation Minimizing, Denying, Blaming Using Children Using Male Privilege Economic Abuse

Use Tab to navigate, Arrow keys to move between sections, Enter/Space to select

Select a Section

Click on any section of the Power and Control Wheel or use your keyboard to navigate (Tab, Arrow keys, Enter) to learn more about that tactic and see examples from the Sumpter case.

Moving Forward

As you complete Module 1, you now have foundational knowledge about:

  • What intimate partner violence is and who it affects
  • The different types of abuse and how they overlap
  • How power and control function in abusive relationships
  • Different categories of relationship violence
  • How these concepts apply to real cases

This foundation prepares you for Module 2, where you'll explore the intersection of intimate partner violence and sexual violence—moving deeper into the iceberg's hidden depths.

Quiz

Question 1 of 3

Case Application

What is the primary purpose of using the Power and Control Wheel to analyze cases like the Sumpter case?